An Analytical Outlook of the Legitimacy of Creation-Science Essay

An Analytical Outlook of the Legitimacy of Creation-Science Essay

Length: 2321 words (6.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

An Analytical Outlook on the Legitimacy of Creation-Science
Dating back to the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century, there has been constant conflict between creationists and evolutionists; one trying to invalidate the other (4). David S. Caudill, the author of “Law and Worldview: Problems in the Creation-Science Controversy,” expresses his perspective using the case of McLean vs. Arkansas Board of Education (1). Like many others, this case attempted to revive the “equal time” statute so that “public school science teachers present both creation and evolution 'theories' in the classroom” (1). Many creationists believe that “'neither evolution nor creation can qualify as scientific theory'” (9) because both entail assumptions about the origin of life without any “conclusive scientific evidence” (9). Although a compelling argument, because of the Establishment Clause in the First Amendment, cases that attempt to introduce creationism into public schools are immediately deemed as unconstitutional (9).
Caudill claims that the McLean court decision was based solely on the inaccurate perceptions of creationism that the defendants presented (14). Although he does not explicitly state which form of evolutionary theory he prefers, Caudill's arguments exhibit the court's inability to judge creationism justly (14). The main criticism expressed in the journal is the oversimplification of how each theory works. In order for the act to not violate the constitution, the court had to determine whether or not there was a 'secular legislative purpose' (20). Caudill believes that the court had “the presumption that creationism was wholly religious and the corollary presumption that evolution was not” (35) and this directly effected the...

... middle of paper ...

...s a concept that was created to protect peoples' religious freedom and it is important that it stays in tact. Despite efforts to prove otherwise, creationism is inherently an attempt to impose religious ideologies onto the public. If the creationists truly only had the intention to educate people about an alternative scientific theory, why would they want to take down the competition? Unless creationists somehow manage to take out the religious motives of their ideology, they need to accept the fact that it will probably never be taught as an independent subject in public schools.

Caudill, David S. “Law and Worldview: Problems in the Creation-Science Controversy.” Journal of Law and Religion Vol. 3, No. 1 (1985): 1-46. JSTOR. Web. 30 April 2014.
Rowe, Bruce and Stein, Philip. Physical Anthropology. New York: Mcgraw-Hill Education, 2014. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Loss of Legitimacy of the British Welfare State Essay

- In the 1940s across industrialised countries, the unique creation of welfare states were introduced. (Lowe, 2005) The term welfare state refers to a society in which the government takes active responsibility for the welfare of citizens living in their jurisdiction. (Lowe, 2005) In the UK, the welfare state consist of policies designed to reflect social need, and includes benefits for those considered to be lower social classes. (Lowe, 2005) Created around the ideas of Beveridge in 1944, the welfare state was a product of liberal form in 1906, and became accepted by Labour in 1945....   [tags: legitimacy crisis ]

Research Papers
2840 words (8.1 pages)

Science Of Science And Science Essay

- Since the times of the Vienna Circle in the early twentieth century, most philosophers have defined science’s epistemic aims in the interlinked concepts of explanation and understanding, laws, unity of science, and causes (IIT). Most theories relating to the above four concepts emphasize generality’s importance in science’s epistemic significance (Nov 2nd handout). This notion of generalization is linked to the underlying belief that science is reducible, and the collective body of sciences aim to be unified and to discover the broad laws of nature (Neurath 306)....   [tags: Science, Scientific method, Philosophy of science]

Research Papers
1266 words (3.6 pages)

The Outlook for Girls In Engineering and Mathematics Essay

- areas of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics employers are not getting enough women (Pozniak). High school girls only represent 17 percent of computer science Advance Placement (AP) test takers (O'Shea). The most significant group of minorities who are behind in earning computer technology degrees and working in science and mathematical professions are women. “Historically, women’s low representation in science and engineering was said to be due in large part of their lack of ability, interest, or both” (Horning 30)....   [tags: Gender Issues]

Research Papers
1889 words (5.4 pages)

Autonomy, Education, and Societal Legitimacy Essay

- Autonomy, Education, and Societal Legitimacy I argue that autonomy should be interpreted as an educational concept, dependent on many educative institutions, including but not limited to government. This interpretation will improve the understanding of autonomy in relation to questions about institutional and societal legitimate authority. I aim to make plausible three connected ideas. (1) Respecting individual autonomy, properly understood, is consistent with an interest in institutions in social and political philosophy....   [tags: Educational Papers]

Research Papers
2939 words (8.4 pages)

Analytical Response to Male Pregnancy Essay

- Analytical Response to Male Pregnancy Male Pregnancy by Dick Teresi and Kathleen McAuliffe support that the technology and the demand for male pregnancy will be possible in the future. They specifically state that, "Someday a man will have a baby". They have written this article in an attempt to show why they believe this will one day become accepted and widely practiced. However, I disagree with Teresi and McAuliffe. I feel male pregnancy will never be freely practiced or accepted by any means....   [tags: Science Technology Essays]

Research Papers
1864 words (5.3 pages)

American Hegemony in the Twenty-First Century: Consensus and Legitimacy

- American Hegemony in the Twenty-First Century: Consensus and Legitimacy Abstract: Since the end of the Cold War, the United States has been the world’s only unquestioned superpower. How the United States evaluates its position as global hegemon has important consequences for American foreign policy, particularly with regards to the potential for future policy constraints. Thus, this paper seeks to consider the question: How durable is American hegemony. The paper first defines the state of American hegemony and then considers the primary challengers: Europe, Russia, China, Japan and imperial overstretch....   [tags: Politics Political Science Essays]

Research Papers
6585 words (18.8 pages)

Medieval Outlook on the Bubonic Plague Essay

- The Medieval Outlook on the Bubonic Plague The Black Death was a major factor in the history of Europe as well as the history of the world. Rivaling the effects of an immense bioterrorist attack, the Black Death was responsible for the taking of over 25 million lives. Creating economic, societal, and medical changes, the Black Death forced Europe to essentially recreate its entire groundwork. At the time of the Black Death, medicine remained very archaic, and European society scrambled to find a cure to this mysterious disease....   [tags: Biology Medical Biomedical Disease Plague]

Research Papers
1446 words (4.1 pages)

job outlook for a teacher Essay

- Job Outlook Overall employment of kindergarten, elementary, and secondary school teachers is expected to increase faster than the average for all occupations through the year 2005, fueled by dramatic growth among special education teachers. However, projected employment growth varies among individual teaching occupations. Job openings for all teachers are expected to increase substantially by the end of the decade as the large number of teachers now in their forties and fifties reach retirement age....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
453 words (1.3 pages)

Switzerlands Financial Outlook Essay

- Switzerland’s Financial Outlook Located in between Italy, France, and Austria, Switzerland is home to a population of 7,450,867 (World Factbook, 2004). In 1848 Switzerland became a federal state that now has 26 cantons and half cantons. Switzerland is a melting pot, consisting of various cultures imported from the several surrounding countries. Languages spoken include French, German, Italian, and Romansch (World Factbook, 2004). For the amount of diversity among its people, it is quite impressive that Switzerland has been the leading European country with the lowest unemployment rate for years (World Factbook, 2004)....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1370 words (3.9 pages)

Analytical Essay

- The construction last year of a shopping mall in downtown Oak City was a mistake. Since the mall has opened, a number of local businesses have closed, and the downtown area suffers from an acute parking shortage. Arrests for crime and vagrancy have increased in nearby Oak City Park. Elm City should pay attention to the example of the Oak City Mall and deny the application to build a shopping mall in Elm City. Analyzing this argument brings up a lot of questions to whether this is a relevant argument or not....   [tags: Analytical Essays]

Free Essays
664 words (1.9 pages)